EPPD officer allegedly runs over family dog, drives away

Updated: Tuesday, August 5 2014, 06:09 PM MDT
EPPD officer allegedly runs over family dog, drives away story image

By: Bill Melugin
EL PASO, Texas-- An east El Paso family is accusing an El Paso Police Department officer of running over their family dog, then driving away and leaving the body.

Mina Mathers tells KFOX14 it happened last Monday at the 1700 block of Plumed Quail, and pointed out a large bloodstain on the street where her 3-year-old Chihuahua Scottie had died.

"I couldn't recognize him because of how much blood was all over him, I recognized him by the collar,” Mathers said. "He was my best friend honestly, he was there for me all the time, I got home and he was always waiting for me.”

Mathers told KFOX14 two of her friends witnessed the officer allegedly run over Scottie and drive away.

She says after her brother removed the body, he confronted a different EPPD officer who had pulled someone over just down the street.

“He was like ‘One of your guys’ units hit our dog, and he's gone,’ and so this officer, the one who pulled someone over, just said ‘Alright well we need to give you guys a ticket because the dog was on the street unattended,” Mathers said. "I understand why we got the ticket, he was only doing his job, but he could care less about that other cop hitting our dog.”

El Paso Police are telling a different story.

In a statement to KFOX14, Sgt. Chris Mears said, “Officers did not issue a citation to the dog owner. If a citation was issued it would have been done by animal control. Also, at the time it was investigated by a police supervisor no witnesses advised having seen a patrol unit strike the dog and a visual inspection of the marked patrol cars that had been in the area did not reveal any evidence supporting this. However, if the dog owner knows of witnesses he or she can contact the Internal Affairs Division. If an officer had struck the animal and been aware of it, the officer should have immediately stopped.”

Mathers told KFOX14 she is “100 percent sure” an EPPD patrol car hit Scottie, and questions how much damage a small Chihuahua can do to a police cruiser.

"People were saying maybe [the officer] didn't feel it, maybe he didn't see it, but it's just like, you're driving around here going no more than 15 miles per hour, and you can't feel that? That's ridiculous,” Mathers said.

Mather’s brother was at work all evening Tuesday and was unable to confirm whether it was police or animal control who cited the family.

Mather’s mother told KFOX14 that the family was cited by an animal control officer.

Mathers told KFOX14 Scottie was an inside dog, and rarely ever got out. She believes he may have gotten out and gone looking for her while she was at a friend’s house up the street.

“It's so lonely, I'm so used if having him around,” Mathers said. "He was one of the one things that I loved, I can say I loved my dog.”

She believes the officer that allegedly ran over Scottie simply didn’t care because it was a small animal.

“He did absolutely nothing about it, he didn't even think twice about it, he didn't think about the emotional stress it caused,” Mathers said. “If it was a kid he hit, yeah, he would stop, don't get me wrong I see the difference between a kid and a dog, but either way they're both a family member.”

EPPD officer allegedly runs over family dog, drives away
comments powered by Disqus

El Paso Times Headlines

Download the new El Paso Times app
Times change, and so has our app. The new El Paso Times app delivers the latest breaking news, in-depth investigations, features and sports stories right to your hands -- wherever you might be.
Romero withdraws former commissioner as city board nominee
City Rep. Larry Romero today withdrew his nomination of former and controversial county commissioner Carlos Aguilar to the City Plan Commission.
Police: Kentucky trooper shooting suspect is shot and killed
EDDYVILLE, Ky. >> A Kentucky state trooper was killed in a shooting during a chase, and officers shot and killed the suspect when he refused to drop his weapon after an hours-long manhunt.
Kentucky clerk won't interfere with gay marriage licenses
MOREHEAD, Ky. >> Clerk Kim Davis returned to work Monday for the first time since being jailed for disobeying a federal judge and said she was faced with a "seemingly impossible choice" between
Trump, Republican campaign light up Spanish-language radio
MIAMI >> The 2016 election is more than a year away but Spanish-language radio is fixated on it.
UTEP football: Miners up against wall after loss
To get the first question out of the way, there is no news on Aaron Jones, which sounds more than a little ominous.
Chihuahuas' Cody Decker called up to San Diego Padres
Cody Decker, the most popular player during the El Paso Chihuahuas' first two seasons, got the call of a lifetime Sunday afternoon – he's going to the Major Leagues.
State: About 2,500 same-sex marriage licenses issued
FORT WORTH, TEXAS >> Texas has issued an estimated 2,500 marriage licenses to same-sex couples since the practice was legalized, nearly 6 percent off all marriage licenses statewide, according to state estimates.
UTEP's future pharmacy school taking shape
University of Texas at El Paso officials are bringing a long-awaited dream to life now that state funding has been secured for a full-fledged School of Pharmacy.
Open house on proposed gas pipeline set for Tuesday
Lower Valley residents who are cautious of a natural gas pipeline cutting their neighborhood will get the details of the project this week.
New deputy commanding general has big training goals
FORT BLISS >> A new leader with the 1st Armored Division has plenty of experience working and training at one of the Army's premier training facilities, and that experience meshes nicely with its training too.
Dem takes aim at Sen. Cruz on Planned Parenthood
Liberal firebrand Elizabeth Warren took to Ted Cruz's home turf Sunday to taunt her U.S. Senate colleague over his high-stakes crusade against Planned Parenthood.
22-year-old man stabbed during fight at Union Plaza
A 22-year-old man was stabbed during a fight at about 2 a.m. Sunday in the Union Plaza area of Downtown El Paso, police reported.
Rescue team helps two hikers get off mountain
The Combined Search and Rescue Team helped two hikers who experienced unidentified medical issues Sunday afternoon climb down from the Franklin Mountains and reach safety, the El Paso Fire Department said.
More than 180 homes destroyed by 2 California blazes
MIDDLETOWN, CALIF. >> Two of California's fastest-burning wildfires in decades overtook several Northern California towns, destroying more than 180 homes and sending residents fleeing Sunday on highways lined with buildings, guardrails and cars still in flames.

Top Stories

Come back often for updates of top national, state and local El Paso area news stories. KFOX covers topics including politics, crime, sports, entertainment, health, economy and other news related subjects. KFOX is dedicated to providing the best, timely and up to date news reporting for El Paso and New Mexico.


KFOX14 El Paso - Live Cast Watch live broadcasts of KFOX14 News seven days a week!